Sur le forum, d'après Ed et John, c'est limite si la différence n'est pas plus esthétique que sonore.
Ed Yoon a écrit :
The Carve Top may end up being around 5% brighter, tighter and more brilliant overall, but it wouldn't take away the low-end response.
Ed Yoon a écrit :
I may have posted this info before but I'll post it here again.
This is going to be a rough generalization, but if we broke down how each type of wood contributes to the overall tonality of the guitar, this is how it would come out:
Body back: 45%
Body top: 5%
Neck wood: 25%
Fingerboard: 25%
Yes, the neck contributes at least 50% of the overall acoustic tone of the instrument. John thinks it may even be a little more - perhaps another 5% or so but not anymore than that. Obviously, on a Carve Top, the thicker top will contribute more to the overall sound - perhaps around 10% with the body back being around 40%.
The thickness of the body and/or neck will also affect the mix as well. John also feels that Flame Maple top sounds a little more even and tighter than Quilted Maple, but we're probably splitting hairs at this point.